Tyler Breshears, the 27-year-old model who sparked headlines on Temptation Island, has officially moved on—with a new girlfriend—just months after the show’s dramatic finale. While he initially left the island hand-in-hand with fitness influencer Kay Carlson, the romance that bloomed during the show didn’t last long once the cameras stopped rolling. Now, Tyler is revealing new details about his breakup with Kay and introducing the world to his new partner, Lauren Bennett, a fitness trainer he met immediately after filming wrapped.
From Long-Term Love to Reality TV Turmoil
When Tyler arrived on Temptation Island, he was in a two-year relationship with Tayler Byrd, 30, a woman he met shortly after separating from his ex-wife. Their relationship began under complicated circumstances, and trust issues were already simmering beneath the surface before they agreed to test their bond on national television.
The Netflix series places couples in separate villas in Hawaii, where they’re surrounded by attractive singles and faced with emotional and romantic temptations. The show’s premise is to explore whether love can survive outside influence—or whether it’s time to move on.
For Tyler, the answer came quickly.
A Sudden Shift Toward Kay Carlson
Only a short time into his stay at the villa, Tyler’s attention turned toward 26-year-old Kay Carlson, a fitness influencer with whom he had immediate chemistry. Viewers watched as their flirty banter escalated to intimate conversations, overnight cuddling, and eventually, their first kiss.
Tyler described a turning point during the show: “There was a moment this morning where I realized I was getting very comfortable with Kay, and I was like, ‘Oh s**t. My relationship is over. And I’m okay with that.’”
After a series of tense bonfire revelations, in which Tayler expressed frustration over financial concerns and emotional disconnects, Tyler felt his connection with Kay was stronger—and chose to end his relationship with Tayler on the island.
Leaving the Island with Kay—But It Didn’t Last
By the end of the season, Tyler and Kay left the island as a new couple. Meanwhile, Tayler opted to leave alone, saying Tyler had hurt her with his dismissive behavior and lack of emotional accountability.
However, fans who rooted for Tyler and Kay were in for a surprise. Shortly after the show wrapped, Tyler revealed that his relationship with Kay fizzled out quickly once real life resumed.
“Non-Existent” Relationship with Kay, Says Tyler
In an exclusive interview with MailOnline, Tyler shared that his romance with Kay is now “non-existent.” He explained that once the show ended, he learned details about Kay that had not been revealed during filming.
“There’s a few things Kay didn’t share with me that I didn’t find out until everything was public afterwards,” he said. “I just got the full picture of who she is, and it didn’t feel right to try a long-distance relationship with someone whose values were questionable to me.”
He also acknowledged that both he and Kay were dealing with post-show emotional stress and agreed it wasn’t the right time for them to continue pursuing a relationship.
Meet Lauren Bennett: Tyler’s New Flame
Not long after filming ended, Tyler met Lauren Bennett, a fitness trainer who would soon become his new girlfriend. The pair were introduced the day after the show wrapped, and their connection slowly evolved into something serious.
“It’s been incredible,” Tyler said of his new relationship. “We’ve taken things slow, she’s been very understanding of this whole process, and it’s just been a gradual build-up. I’m in a great mood now because I’ve found someone fantastic.”
He recently went Instagram official with Lauren, sharing a cozy photo of the two and debuting their romance to fans who were eager for an update.
Social Media Reactions and Fan Support
Tyler’s reveal sparked a flurry of reactions on social media. While some viewers criticized his behavior toward Tayler and Kay during the show, others applauded his honesty and were excited to see him in a seemingly healthier relationship. His openness about post-show emotional growth and his desire for a real connection resonated with fans who felt he had matured since filming.
Reflecting on Tayler Byrd and the Past
Tyler’s original relationship with Tayler Byrd had already weathered its fair share of storms before entering the show. The couple met during a delicate time—shortly after Tyler’s separation from his ex-wife—and began dating four months later. Unfortunately, he was unfaithful just a month into their relationship, and the trust never fully recovered.
On the show, financial tension also took center stage, with Tayler expressing frustration over supporting Tyler after he left his job in medical sales to pursue modeling. Their differences, both emotional and practical, made their breakup seem inevitable as the season progressed.
What’s Next for Tyler Breshears?
As of 2025, Tyler is fully focused on his new relationship with Lauren and rebuilding his personal life away from the intense scrutiny of reality television. Although his time on Temptation Island was packed with controversy, it appears he’s landed in a more stable and grounded place.
Fans can expect to see more of Tyler and Lauren on social media as they share glimpses into their fitness-focused lifestyles and travels. Whether or not he returns to TV remains unknown, but it’s clear that Tyler Breshears is ready to leave the island—and the drama—behind.
